A Perfect Manhattan

Brian and I agree on many things—oh, that The Barefoot Contessa is smug and annoying (but not as smug or annoying as Michael Chiarello); that anchovies are severely underappreciated; that chicken's fine, but pork is better. But when it comes to that intoxicatingly complex and perfect-for-winter cocktail known as the Manhattan, we belong to decidedly different schools. Brian likes his rich, dark, and luscious, like the Pegu Club's interpretation with Woodford Bourbon, while I prefer the zesty and ultra-dry rendition served up at Angel's Share. But our differences notwithstanding, last week we set about to mix a Manhattan we both could love.
We began with our one point in common, and that concerns the cherry. No hum-drum maraschino cherry would tarnish our lovely drink—only a tangy, deep-purple amarena cherry would do. With that settled, we moved on to the main event. The starting point was Old Overholt rye, the same stuff as in my Angel's Share cocktail. After a little back and forth, we found the Perfect Manhattan—with half sweet vermouth and half dry—to be the, er, perfect compromise. To make our drink a bit special, we also mixed in a splash of the amarena cherry syrup—one teaspoon for Brian, half a teaspoon for me. The result was an ultra-smooth, easy-drinking cocktail that I know we'll be making again. And remember, kids—stir, don't shake, this one!
A PERFECT MANHATTAN
2 ounces rye
1/2 ounce sweet vermouth
1/2 ounce dry vermouth
1/2-1 teaspoon amarena cherry syrup
a couple dashes Angostura bitters
2 amarena cherries
Drop cherries into a martini glass. Combine remaining ingredients in a cocktail shaker with a few ice cubes. Stir well. Pour into the martini glass.
Be sure to visit Imbibe magazine's blog for more quaffable winter warmers!
Category: Drinks
Copyright (c) 2007 Sarah Kiino, www.avenuefood.com. My RSS feed is for personal, noncommercial use only. If you are perusing this post on a site that is neither www.avenuefood.com, nor your news aggregator, the Web site you are reading has likely stolen my material, and I'd like to know about it. Please send me an e-mail at avenuefoodAThotmailDOTcom. Thanks for your assistance in this matter.





I LOVE mixing new, perfected drinks!
I need a pink cocktail to salute my friends' ongoing battle with breast cancer---I am thinking a week of pink drinks and food... any ideas?
Reply to this
Janelle--that is a wonderful idea. I blogged about a pomegranate champagne cocktail awhile back (http://avenuefood.com/2006/12/04/pomegranate-champagne-cocktail.aspx). It's kind of pink--you could make it more so by decreasing the amount of pomegranate juice. Or there's always the good ol' Cosmo.
Good wishes to you and your friend . . .
Reply to this
I was in L.A. during the Sylmar quake in 1971. The bartender at our local haunt, the Chez Edward, created his "Earthquake Special" to celebrate surviving "the big one".
It's one part Sloe Gin, two parts Vodka and served like a Manhattan, in a martini glass with a red cherry and a little cherry juice for flavor. You can also serve it over the rocks.
It may or may not be enjoyable for you, but it's definitely pink!
Reply to this
Thanks Frank! I e-mailed your comment to Janelle in case she doesn't see it here.
Reply to this
Why not three cherries? My parents insist upon that...
Reply to this
Hey, why not? I'm all for lots of cherries.
Reply to this
Definitely, a perfect manhattan has to have lots of cherries, Similar recipe ( http://www.rapidsloth.com )
Reply to this
I'd forgotten how much I love Manhattans until this interpretation reminded me. Now I have an excuse to buy a bottle of rye.
Reply to this
Ha ha--no excuse necessary. Enjoy the cocktail!
Reply to this
I tried this last night. Very tasty. My kind of cooking!
Reply to this
Excellent! I'll let Brian know you approve.
Reply to this
Do you knowlast chaos gold?if you play the online game,you will knowlastchaos goldis the game gold.if you had more lc gold,you can had a tall level.you can come here and spend a little money to boughtbuy last chaos gold.Quickly come here.
Reply to this
This is a nice food!
Reply to this
swg credits in which world have one feature. First of all, realize the Star Wars Galaxies credits is useful to the each new player.
Reply to this
Thanks for the post. Keep the great work.
Reply to this
swg credits in which world have one feature. First of all, realize the Star Wars Galaxies credits is useful to the each new player. You only play with others and swg Gold can get happy from the game.
Reply to this
Do not enough cash to buy a building? You not have to worry, just because this is achievable to take the business loans to resolve all the problems. Hence get a auto loan to buy all you want.
Reply to this